Thoughts and updates on recent trade news

Please see the following message from Ted Murphy of Sidley Austin LLP reviewing and summarizing trade developments over the past couple of days.

(1) US-Canada & the Future of USMCA

As you may have seen if you have been watching the World Series, the Province of Ontario ran an anti-tariff commercial featuring excerpts from a radio address given by former President Ronald Reagan in 1987.  President Trump was not impressed.  He said that the ad was a blatant attempt to influence the U.S. Supreme Court’s consideration of the lawsuits challenging the tariffs Trump has imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (i.e., the fentanyl tariffs and the reciprocal tariffs). In response, he initially announced on social media that “all trade negotiations with Canada are hereby terminated” (of course, President Trump used ALL CAPS).  He later announced that United States would increase tariffs on Canada by an additional 10% (can a TV ad contribute to the “national emergency” related to fentanyl imports from Canada?).  We expect to see something official from the White House on the additional 10% tariff early this week.

This does not bode well for the United States-Canada-Mexico Agreement (USMCA), which will be under review in 2026 (the Office of U.S. Trade Representative is currently accepting comments on the future of USMCA).  Our base case is that the United States withdraws from USMCA by the end of 2026 and replaces it with two bilateral agreements (one with Mexico and one with Canada).  On the Canadian side, we are expecting a pretty narrow sectoral-type agreement that covers big issues like energy, aluminum, lumber, maybe autos (although autos will be the reason Trump pulls the USA out of USMCA) and then some smaller issues like dairy.  This latest dust up just makes this outcome more likely (in our view).

(2) Agreements with Cambodia, Malaysia, Vietnam and Thailand

President Trump is currently in Asia for various meetings.  Thus far, he has announced agreements on reciprocal trade with Cambodia and with Malaysia, and the frameworks for agreements with Vietnam and Thailand.

The agreements on reciprocal trade with Cambodia and with Malaysia are noteworthy for a couple of reasons.  First, they appear to be true trade agreements (not just Executive branch agreements) with provisions for tariffs, non-tariff barriers, agriculture, geographical indicators, electronic transmissions, IP, services, labor issues, etc.  Since the Constitution gives the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations to Congress, it will be interesting to see if President Trump submits these agreements to Congress for ratification. The President does not have Trade Promotion Authority, so if he does, Congress may try to amend the agreements.  If he does not, and relies on IEEPA instead, then the agreements may be at risk based on what the Supreme Court decides in the pending challenge to the IEEPA tariffs.  Second, these agreements preserve the parties’ ability to impose new rules of origin if the benefits of the agreement “are accruing substantially to third countries or third-country nationals[.]” This is commonly understood to mean limiting the amount of Chinese involvement (though ownership and/or through content) in the articles that get preferential treatment under the agreement (i.e., a lower tariff rate).

(3) Negotiations with China

The United States and China are at odds on a host of issues.  The United States has imposed additional tariffs on products of China, (20% IEEPA fentanyl; 125% IEEPA reciprocal tariff later reduced temporarily to 10%); additional fees on Chinese shipping; imposed additional export controls; threatened additional tariffs of 100%; initiated investigations into China’s compliance with the Phase 1 agreement from Trump’s first term, etc.  China, for its part, has imposed corresponding tariffs on products of the United States, tightened its export controls on rare earths, initiated investigations into various U.S. companies and industries; not purchased U.S. agricultural products, etc.

The two sides have been talking, however; and President Trump and President Xi are scheduled to meet this Thursday.  It is being reported that the two leaders will review a framework for a deal to reduce trade tensions.  While nothing is certain, a deal that includes no new tariffs, the United States lowering the existing IEEPA fentanyl tariff, China agreeing to substantial U.S. agricultural purchases, relaxed/delayed export controls by both sides, and something on the U.S. shipping fees would not be surprising.  President Trump is in “deal mode” and is unlikely to let the opportunity of meeting with President Xi in person get away without a deal.  For China’s part, we expect that they will drive a tough bargain.


If you have any questions, please contact our office.